Filet-o-Fish Copycat Sandwich
Rated 3.7 stars by 54 users
Servings
4
Prep Time
10 minutes
Cook Time
10 minutes
Skip the drive-thru line and make your favorite fast food fish sandwich at home.
Author:Jessica Bentley
Ingredients
4 - 6 oz. White Fish Filets (Pollock, Flounder, Cod, or Mahi-Mahi)
1 tsp. Salt
1.5 cups All-Purpose Flour + more for dredge
1 tbsp. Garlic Powder
2 tsp. Cayenne
1 tsp. Old Bay Seasoning
2 tsp. White Pepper
1 Egg
12 oz. Pilsner Beer
8 Slices American Cheese
-
1 Bottle of Duke’s Tidewater Tartar Sauce
4 Brioche Buns
Vegetable Oil, for frying
Directions
Fill a large pot with enough oil to cover the filets and heat until the oil has reached 365F. While the oil is heating, prep the rest of the ingredients for the sandwiches.
If needed, trim the white fish filets to a little larger than the size of the buns. Season with salt and allow them to sit for 5 - 10 minutes at room temperature.
In a large bowl, mix together the 1.5 cups flour with garlic powder, cayenne, old bay, and white pepper. Next add the egg, pilsner and whisk together to make a batter.
Add some flour to a plate and fully coat the fish filets with flour followed by the batter. Working in two batches, drop 2 filets into the oil and fry for 5 minutes. Drain fish on a wire rack with a lined baking sheet underneath.
Lay out the buns, toast them if you prefer, and pile each with a fried fish filet, two slices of cheese, and desired amount of tartar sauce. Finish with the top bun. Enjoy immediately.
Recipe Note
· The cheese will slightly melt when assembled on top of the hot fried fish filet. You could alternatively use a blow torch or place them in an 350F oven for a few minutes or until your desired melty preference.
· I buy the “deluxe” American cheese slices at the grocery store for this sandwich. However, if you have the plastic wrapped kind… that’ll work too!
· If you trim the fish filets, go ahead and flour then batter the trims to make fish nuggets! Dunk them in the Duke’s Tartar Sauce and you’re all set. Depending on the size, fry time will vary. Just make sure the internal temperature has reached 130F before enjoying.